.
Portia
.
Hello Fellow Fumies,
Every Saturday we have a Question, an idea purloined from Olfactoria’s Travels. Everyone gets to chime in with an answer, chat with other responders and it is a fun event each week. Taking sides never means taking offence and everyone keeps it respectful and light, even though we can sometimes trawl the depths.
The idea is you’ll see it on the weekend or chime in through the week. Hopefully you will come back and see if anyone has responded to your comment and you can reply to them.
Over 100 responses I will draw a Scent Sample Pack (from my collection)
This week:
Rose Sample Pack
- Neela Vermeire Creations Mohur
- Yves Rocher Rose Oud
- Vintage Paco Rabanne Calandre
- Olympic Orchids Ballets Rouges
- Diptyque Rose de Mai
Last Weeks Winner:
eMail me at (portia underscore turbo at yahoo dot com dot au) with your address please
Saturday Question: What Are Your Favourite Rose Scents?
Rose has been a stalwart fragrance note for centuries. Almost everyone can find a rose that suits them. From the simple sharp green of Perfumer’s Workshop Tea Rose to the rich and textured Rochas Byzance there are thousands of stops in between. Wet, sweet, fruity, musk and oud roses galore, especially in the last five years.
I can’t wait to read your favourites and why they are.
My Answer:
You all know how much I love DIOR Oud Ispahan or Mitzah, Yves Rocher Rose Oud, JHaG Midnight Oud, Guerlain Rose Nacree or Nahema, Olympic Orchids Ballets Rouges, SOIVOHLE Rosa Sur Reuse, Serge Lutens La Fille de Berlin and Fille en Aiguilles. Roses are a huge part of my fragrance wardrobe. Sometimes as a pivotal note, others as backup.
Parfumo gives these featured accords:
Top: Ambrette seed, Elemi resin, Cardamom, Carrot seed, Coriander seed, Black pepper
Heart: Hawthorn, Iris, Jasmine, Leather, Almond milk, Moroccan rose, Turkish rose, Violet
Base: Amber, Benzoin, Blond woods, Oud, Patchouli, Sandalwood, Tonka bean, Vanilla
The fragrance I reach for most when roses are in my head is Neela Vermeire Creations Mohur. Yes, I’m sure it’s no surprise to any of you. There is something so glamorous, rich and spectacular about wafting such a multi faceted scent created with such love. Having worn Mohur for years now here in Australia and around the world I not only smell the scent of it but also have wonderful flashbacks to times worn away, doing amazing things with friends and seeing the world. Neela is also a mate of ours so I’m also spritzing her friendship every time.
LuckyScent has $235/60ml
Surrender To Chance has samples from $7/0.5ml
Rose Potion or Rose Embers from Teone Reinthal Natural Perfumes – the freshest dewyest rose note I’ve ever smelled.
LikeLike
OOOH! I think I have a sample of this one. thanks Monica.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Both are beautiful, but my fave Teone rose must be Rosalie. It is a tomboy’s rose. Playful, light and oh so green!
LikeLike
Une Rose. OMG it’s so, so beautiful.
LikeLike
Oh yes it is.
Did you get my eMail Ros?
Portia xx
LikeLike
Mohur is one of my favourite rose fragrances as well, both in EDP and in Extrait. I also like Nahéma but shame that the current EDP doesn’t last. Rose Barbare is quite nice too though a bit too much honeyed for me. Nicolaï’s Rose Royale from last year is a gorgeous take on fresh roses. Rive Gauche in vintage form is another of my favourite.
On the darker woodier side there’s Guerlain’s Rose Nacrée du Désert which I’m currently enjoying a lot and debating whether to get a full bottle. Rose Nacrée somewhat reminds me of Malle’s Portrait of a Lady, but that one I’m not too fond of. I’m not sure why. It smells quite lovely to begin with, but to my nose it just keeps “shouting” with the same voice afterwards and maybe that’s what bores me. I enjoy Diptyque’s Oud Palao as well, but it’s really really similar to Oud Ispahan.
Smolderose from January Scent Project is quite an interesting take on roses. The roasted seashells add a salty and slightly marine (not that calone kind of marine) facet to the rose. I quite like it as well.
As you see I’m a huge rose fragrance fan! One that I need to check out next is Aramis Callligraphy Rose, but it’s so rare and basically impossible to sample. Fighting the urge to blind buy a bottle…
LikeLike
I remember STC had samples of Calligraphy Rose, do they not carry it anymore?
Portia xx
LikeLike
Just checked, seems not. Anyway since I’m in France, the shipping is a bit too much for a sample.
LikeLike
Smolderose fan girl here. The ashy take on rose brings out the inner Carmen in me.
LikeLike
I am a huge rose lover. In my collection, I have roses of all sorts because I reach for different ones depending on my mood,season and weather condition. I enjoy Roses and More, Nightingale’s cup, Caron Rose. Parfait des Roses, Rosa Nobile and Sloan Rose when it is warm and when it starts turning cooler, I reach for Ensar Rose by SPA, Calligraphy Rose, Miroir des Majestes, David Yurman Extrait, Rosam, John Galliano, Smolderose and Rose Potion.
LikeLike
What a blooming rose garden of scents you have BBMc.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Mohur Extrait is breathtaking…a rose I adored and miss very much due to its discontinuation status is Pacifica’s Egyptian Bergamot Rose (but the middle Marzipan has this in solid perfume so I often steal a few whiffs from the tin)….I also really like Eden Botanicals Egyptian Rose 10 % and Jasmine Rose 10%.
LikeLike
and do not enter me 🙂
LikeLike
That reads REALLY wrong CM.
Portia xxx
LikeLike
😂😂😂
LikeLike
oh my lord!!!!! delete that comment-LOL!!!!!
can I blame it on beyond middle age brain?????
LikeLike
I love you more and more each week, CM. Truly. Bahahahahahaha!
LikeLike
Hahahahahaha, I had to read it carefully once again. My brain is functioning so innocently 😀
LikeLike
FWIW, I knew exactly what you meant. Why is everyone’s brain in the gutter 🤔
LikeLike
Y’all are really making me laugh..which is why I always love popping in here!
LikeLike
My favorite is Penhaligon’s Vaara. I also really like Sunflowers Dream Petals, Calligraphy Rose, and Narciso For Her.
LikeLike
Hey there Amanda,
I love Narciso For Her too.
Portia xx
LikeLike
L`Eau d`Issey Florale by Issey Miyake is my favourite rose scent. Smells very girly.
LikeLike
I never knew L`Eau d`Issey Florale was rose based AnnetZ.
Portia xx
LikeLike
The fragrance features mandarin orange, rose, lily and woodsy notes.
LikeLike
4160 Tuesday’s Who Knew? is my favourite perfume of the last year and am already halfway through a bottle. Sitill have a bit of Yves Rocher’s Rose Ansolue sweet and a bit boozy.
LikeLike
Slowly making my way through the 4160 Tuesdays oeuvre AnnieA,
Sarah is remarkably fecund.
Portia xx
LikeLike
My favorite rose fragrances are Frederic Malle Lipstick Rose followed by Guerlain Nahema.
LikeLike
Kathleen, You can congratulate yourself on having impeccable taste. Great choices.
Portia xx
LikeLike
And how could I forget Amouage Lyric?
LikeLike
I do love rose as a note but tend not to like soliflores so much.
But a favourite? Hmmm 🤔
Well, my obsession with Rive Gauche has been well documented, then there is Magie Noire, Rose Nacree and Coco….but the Rose in these fragrances is like Shelley Winters in The Poseidon Adventure – a big star with a huge supporting cast.
If I had to pick one it would be Knowing. It is *mostly* rose to my nose (with some moss, woods and 80’s shoulder pads in there too)
It feels somewhat subtle, dry and masculine when I wear it. The total opposite of what I usually wear 😂 And, it’s longevity is amazing. Hangs around all day.
Another interesting question thanks P!
LikeLike
Don’t forget the ABBA link with Knowing Me, Knowing you too Scott.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Whoa, hang on, Scott! Knowing – rose?? Ok…I need to wear it again to see. Screams oakmoss to me…
LikeLike
Oh yes to Rive Gauche and Coco!!!!
LikeLike
I’m not a huge rose fan, but I do love Mohur and Tobacco Rose by Papillon.
LikeLike
Oh Mary,
How could I forget Tobacco Rose! What a stellar scent.
Portia xx
LikeLike
OMG Tobacco Rose is fabulous.
LikeLike
Oooh I haven’t tried that yet!
LikeLike
I love Andy Tauer’s Une rose chyprée (spelling?), but it is complex and I have to be in the mood for it, if not it annoys me after a couple of hours. I also own a bottle of JHaG Citizen Queen, easier to wear. There’s at least one perfume I really wish I had bought while it was still produced, Enlèvement au Sérail. Hope so much that beautiful, sensual blend of jasmine and rose will return one day.
Generally I don’t buy very rose-sentric perfumes, I prefer just smelling rose perfume briefly, so more on others than on myself.
LikeLike
Hey Ingeborg,
Enlèvement au Sérail is gorgeous, such a beautiful frag.
Portia xx
LikeLike
If you’d asked me this a few weeks back I would have said Portrait of a Lady, but something may have stolen her crown. I recently got E Coudray Rose Tuberose and am blown away by that. It is a close run race is all I can say. I came late to the Rose party, and only after smelling Paul Smith Rose did I realise that I liked rose in a perfume. So that was my gateway, and I still wear it and get loads of compliments too.
LikeLike
Hey Cassieflower,
It’s so hard to make definite judgements when there’s always something new and interesting in perfume that can turn your head. Glad to have you on board with roses nowadays.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Tauer roses are my favourites: PHI, Rose Vermeille, Rose Chypree, Incense Rose. I also enjoy Papillon Tobacco Rose and Dior Colle Noire.
LikeLike
PHI!!! I forgot about that one!!! that is my favorite of Andy’s roses.
LikeLike
Rose Chypree is the rosiest I can enjoy. Im really like it.
LikeLike
And his Rose Flash as well!
LikeLike
Which of Andy’s roses has that metallic shriek through it? Whichever it is is the one I love.
LikeLike
Phi and URV are two of my favorite roses too.
LikeLike
I am a rose addict. My tops are Perfumer’s Workshop Tea Rose, Tauerville Rose Flash, LUSH Imogen Rose, Serge Lutens La Fille de Berlin and Sa Majeste. There are so many more. Calligraphy Rose and a few others like Angel Schlesser.
LikeLike
Woo Hoo! ONE OF US ONE OF US! Glad to see another rose ho Gina.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Annick Goutal’s Ce Soir ou Jamais and Rose Absolue, and April Aromatics Rosenlust. Lovely to read everyone’s comments!
LikeLike
YAY! Good choices Hamamelis. We haven’t seen you for a while, everything OK?
Portia xx
LikeLike
Hi Portia, thank you so much for asking. Our business is growing fast which is great but also too too busy! Health isn’t so robust, nothing new but energies are limited! I hope Jin and the dogs are ok!
LikeLike
Have loved roses / Rose, since forever (yes, I’ve been around, lol)… I read everyone’s response so far, and the last one (Hamamelis – witchhazel, lol) mentioned Goutal’s Ce Soir our Jamais, which is the one I favor when I need a rich, opulent rose fix… I think it owes it’s pedigree to that uber classic of Rose & Jasmine i.e. Patou’s Joy. Another beautiful rose experience. A more contemporary version of the Queen of Flowers that I enjoy is ‘Rose Ideal’ by Anonyme. A very pink rose, light, airy, a bit of the stem and leaves, but yet quintessentially Rose – definitely a soliflore. The rose note, as the jasmine note are both stalwarts of the perfume pyramid, almost ubiquitous in most floral fragrances, and sometimes even in those that are not primarily known as ‘florals’. Salve Rosa, long may she reign.
LikeLike
YAY! Excellent response Z
Portia xx
LikeLike
Not a big rose fan but I do like Parfum Sacre, Lyric, Rose de Nuit and Saffron Troublant. So spicy and or with incense.
LikeLike
They are four feisty roses Mariann,
Portia xx
LikeLike
Thanks for reminding me about Saffron Troublant….I love that one too
LikeLike
I wear Rose Nacre du Dessert for glamour and Lush Rose Jam for fun. SHL 777 Rose de Petra is on my FB list.
LikeLike
Lovely choices SunnyDay.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Parfums Gres Cabaret. Rose is prominent but so well blended, woody, and sophisticated.
LikeLike
YAY! Life isa a ……
Portia xx
LikeLike
Ooh, what a question! I’m a huge fan of rose-based perfumes, my biggest favourites being Parfum Sacre, La Fille de Berlin, Rouge d’Hermes and Kazimi. All of these are roses mixed with spices and/or woods, but I also like wearing, – less often nowadays, – rose chypres such as Agent Provocateur, 900 or Paloma.
Never tried Mohur but it sounds great!
LikeLike
I ended up giving away my bottle of Parfum Sacre. I lost my love for it.
LikeLike
Oh, I have a couple backups. True love here 🙂
LikeLike
Me either but it sounds gorgeous.
LikeLike
What a lovely line up of roses Diana,
I still love the original Agent Provocateur, so good.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Thank you, Portia! Yes, AP is gorgeous. A friend gave me a sample of it, the juice was produced in the early 2000-es. I wonder if it’s changed drastically since then …
LikeLike
Not a huge rose fan but there are 3 that I love Nahema, Une Folie de Rose, and L’Arte di Gucci.
LikeLike
I had a sample of L’Arte do Gucci forever and tried it only recently: what a wonderful perfume! I’m not surprised by the price for it on eBay.
LikeLike
Hey Sara,
Une Folie de Rose is a very nice Parfum de Rosine. Pretty yet gives an impression of strength.
Portia xx
LikeLike
I love L’Arte, too.
LikeLike
L’Arte di Gucci is super awesome. I am glad I have it in both edt and edp. It was so hard to come by in good price initially that I resorted to buying edp minis at first.
LikeLike
It’s funny; I say I’m not a rose fan, but there are 3 I adore and could swim in. Teone’s Rosalie, one of Andy Tauer’s – the one with a screeching metallic note – and Smolderose by January Scent Project. Beside these, I really do not seek out rose scents. I own a few, such as Nahema, Body something by Burberry, a stach of modern Chloes, etc, but they rarely make it out of the hardly ever wear basket.
To top it off, my yardstick of rose perfection was shaped by 70s rose scented bubble baths and Yardley sprays. Soliflore type rose scents. Nothing like them.
Rose throws me into a contradictory mess.
LikeLike
For the longest time,mI kept telling myself I don’t like florals but lo and behold, I do have quite a few floral florals!
LikeLike
YAY for being a contradictory mess Kate,
I don’t need roses for that but it’s good you’ve found your trigger.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Smolderose by January Scent Project. I also like ELDO Rossy de Palma Eau de Protection and Portrait of a Lady but reading this thread brings home how many more I’ve yet to try. Harvesting all the suggestions 🙂
LikeLike
One of the things I love most about these threads Earl Gray are the reminders of frags in boxes that I need to grab out and spritz. Harvesting suggestions is a wonderful way to put it.
Portia xx
LikeLike
I love so many already named: Mohur in both versions, PoaL, Tobacco Rose, Fille de Berlin, Une Rose, Smolderose . . . But a new one to me and for those who like rose and pathoulyc here with amazing coriander too, Note di Profumum Maraviglio. It’s amazing. Also Hendley’s Rosenthal.
LikeLike
I keep seeing Smolderose I better try it. I think I have a sample from LuckyScent.
LikeLike
Last I looked he had a sampler pack on sale….if you go directly to his website…just sayin’ 🙂
LikeLike
OOOH! Sounds fabulous Amy.
Thanks,
Portia xx
LikeLike
I hope there is more than 100 responses so I have a chance at winning that stash.
Being such a new rose lover I’m trying to sniff so many more. My fave right now is Tiziana Terenzi Gold Rose Oudh of course. Closely followed by ELDO Eau De Protection. But I also want FM aims Rose and Lipstick Rose. And maybe one day the Serge roses… I really could go on!
LikeLike
Heh, then reply back to some of th comments. I thought for sure there would be one for last week’s!
LikeLike
Replying! I will reply away 🙂
LikeLike
HA! Yeah, we had 85 responses last week. That was a surprise because I thought you’d all get really excited about it. Fingers crossed for this week.
Portia xx
LikeLike
I know, right?! I would’ve thought L’Artisan would get more love 🙂
LikeLike
La Fille de Berlin for dark & spicy.
Grace by Grace Coddington for green & fresh.
In Love Again for fruity & juicy.
Galop for rose & leather.
Santal Majescule for sandalwood & spices.
Rossy de Palma for don’t mess with me…
There are others I wear like Coco and L’Ombre dans L’eau which do have significant rose notes but somehow I don’t think if them as ‘rose perfumes’.
LikeLike
Oh and I recently tested Fort & Manle’s Charletan and am now seriously considering whether I don’t also need a frag with dark roses, jasmine and rich dark unsweetened chocolate vanilla amber truffles…
LikeLike
Um…… YES! You definitely need it Lillibet. He He he.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Oh and CAFE ROSE! Can’t believe I forgot that one! Roses and coffee…
LikeLike
I need to get La Fille de Berlin I think!
LikeLike
You should, it’s gorgeous!
LikeLike
It’s probably my second favourite Lutens after Gingembre. Just gorgeous!
LikeLike
I agree on Mohur, it’s such a beauty and very wearable in any occasion.
I’m a fan of Rose Velours from the VC&A Collection Extraordinaire, which is a woody rose and my latest flame is Penhaligon’s Much Ado About the Duke, a spicy rose with a touch of leather and alcohol. Exquisite.
LikeLike
YAY Neva,
SNAP on Mohur.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Some that immed. come to mind include Nombre Noir, Ungaro Diva, Lutens Fille d’Berlin, and Amouage Lyric Woman.
LikeLike
I love smelling Diva but I’m not sure I can wear it: it seems like TOO MUCH – and I actually like loud perfumes!
LikeLike
A group of us got kicked out of the Art Gallery of NSW Members Lounge for spritzing DIVA Undina. It’s enormous!
Portia xx
LikeLike
But at least it is awesome, right 😀
LikeLike
I love the Taif rose and saffron of Rising Phoenix Perfume’s Sheik Khalifa. My second love is Ensar Rose of Sultan Pasha Attars.
LikeLike
Ooh, I should check out that Rising Phoenix! I have and love Sicilian Vanilla.
LikeLike
My favorites are Vero Profumo Rozy edp, Tauer Phi, Tauer Incense Rose, and Ormonde Jayne Ta’if!
LikeLike
HOW could I forget ROZY Christine. Good reminder.
Portia xx
LikeLike
One of my favorites – NVC Mohur Extrait!
LikeLike
YES!!!!!!!
LikeLike
SNAP!
Portia xx
LikeLike
Harem Rose by Fort and Manle and Kimono Rose by Boise 1920 – both absolutely stunning rose scents.
LikeLike
I remember how much I loved Roger & Gallet Rose Thé, and Yardley’s English Rose – the former in scented soaps, the latter in eau de toilette. I felt like a sophisticated 11 year old!
These days I grow and adore roses, but I can’t wear many, for some reason – I gave away my split of Ce Soir ou Jamais, for example, because I just didn’t like it after the first half hour. I do love my sample of La Fille de Berlin, though.
LikeLike
Hi there Empliau,
La Fille de Berlin is very special. I love it too.
Portia x
LikeLike
I love Rose, but I feel like I’m getting too picky with it for my own good. So I only really have two rose loves in
1. Frederic Malle – Portrait of a Lady
2. Papillon – Tobacco Rose
I am yet to try Mohur but it sounds very promising!
LikeLike
Stephen,
Please come over one day for a rose sniff.
I think there might be 30 or 40 rose centric fragrances in this room.
Portia xx
LikeLike
Hahaha you’ll blow my nostrils right off my face but I’d love to!
LikeLike
I loveeeeeeeeeee POAL vintage. How could I forget to list it.
LikeLike
Last year I did a month of roses (February), so I have many favorite rose perfumes in my collection. But if I had to name just, let’s say, five – Ormonde Jayne Ta’if, Amouage Lyric, Frederic Malle Portrait of a Lady, Les Parfums de Rosine Rose d’Amour and Le Labo Rose 31. But I could go on and on and on… I should probably go back to reading everybody’s replies to join my vote for those beautiful perfumes that didn’t get to my mini-list.
LikeLike
Oh yes,
I knew you are a rose lover Undine, I can imagine you swanning around and wafting the most fabulous roses each and every way. One day when we meet I hope I’m wearing roses for you.
Portia xx
LikeLike
I just thought of three more- Dame Perfumery Rose de Mai, Dame Perfumery Desert Rose and Dame Perfumery Cassis, Rose & Sandalwood.
LikeLike
I have a sample of Desert Rose, must find it and give it a sniff.
LikeLike
One day I will learn to stop worrying and love the rose. Most just seem to turn a bit thin and sour on me while they bloom on everyone else. (Though Fille de Berlin works on me, I seem to have gone moths without wearing it.)
But I think I have now found a rose that fits me: the voile of rozy.
LikeLike
These days I am all about modern takes on rose, and am quite partial to Jeffrey Dame’s Cassis, Rose & Sandalwood and also his Rose de Mai ❤
LikeLike
Fun times reading the comments. I adore fresh-cut roses from the garden, especially the highly scented ones. But I favor perfumes with roses blended into a floral bouquet. I do love PW Tea Rose, just a light spritz is enough. And I miss the R&G rose soaps, they were beautiful.
LikeLike