.
Val the Cookie Queen
.
Hey APJ
I was in Vienna last week to see the New York based band Brass Against. The Resistance Tour. They were performing in a small club, maximum 350 people. The band play covers of classic songs by Audioslave, Tool, Back Sabbath, Rage Against the Machine ……. They are political in a time where a lot of bands sit on the wall twiddling their thumbs, not wanting to upset their fan base. Brass Against are not here for the Instagram likes. Hardcore and absolutely brilliant; as mind-blowing as when I first saw The Clash.
Brass Against. Wake Up!
As luck would have it the venue was a mere ten minutes walk from the Chanel Exclusif counter.
1957 by Olivier Polge for Les Exclusifs de Chanel 2018
“In a society where speed is everything, perfumes are judged in a couple of seconds, as if at a glance. The hastiness of these assessments upsets me: a perfume can only tell its story when it is smelled and worn.” JEAN-CLAUDE ELLENA
It opens with an aldehydic blast, green, quite sharp, with some rose and coriander. It doesn’t last long until the neroli shows. It is full of white musks. These are the building blocks of the perfume; some tinged with orange blossom, some with cedar, some with pink pepper. I notice different nuances each time I wear it. Rippled with golden honey, and a touch of iris. Deceptively simple, it is a work of genius. We live in frenzied times, permanent-stress, hostilities, and ugly politics. 1957 is elegant, polished, and a scent of impeccable beauty. It glows.
White musks, Bergamot, Iris, Neroli, Cedar and Honey.
It has been interesting reading people’s comments online. Most of them probably written after one try, and I suspect some of them without any try. “I hate white musk.” “This is not Coromandel.” No kidding, perhaps you don’t know you can go and buy Coromandel? People are so stupid. You know what 1957 could be though? N°5. But we have that already. 1957 has about an 18 hour longevity, well sprayed. Divine.
If you are looking for cat pee and leather, patchouli and smoke, then move on. 1957 will not be for you. But please grab a few spritzes if you have the chance. And don’t be hasty in your assessment.
I bought the Chanel Paris-Venise in Vienna, and nearly bought the 1957 too. But the wonderful SA gave me a 4ml mini and a couple of atomiser samples. Told me to take my time with it.
Does a great gig or a new Chanel Exclusif excite you as much as me?
Beautiful Bussis
CQ
Check out the Candy Perfume Boy and Colognoisseur for more.
Haven’t been to any gig in eons. Sh#$t, Val, now I really want to try 1957. Thanks for creating a lemming LOL.
Sadly I have never had any luck getting samples. The few trips I make into the city and I still come home empty handed. The last time I was at a Chanel counter you would have thought that I was asking the SA for one of her vital organs when I asked for a manufacturer sample of Coramandel. After a two hour train ride home I realized she gave me Misia instead. This is my luck. I agree with you that one needs to live in a fragrance before deciding. I would be willing to live in 1957. I like pretty and not overly complicated. Plus the year 1957 is significant for me……look at me making every excuse to try this lol
Thanks for the great review, Val, and for reminding us to savor our perfumes.
LikeLike
Pfff, for a moment I thought you’d violate the no-buy resolution…ok, free samples are welcome any time 🙂
LikeLike
Hahaha!!! So far so good on the no buy….all I have to do is look at all the bottles strewn around the house…granted they’re technically NOT all mine but I can and do wear them…..and then there’s my essential oils 🤦🤦🤦🤦
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m starting to wonder how the hell I’m ever going to make a dent in my perfume. And yet, here I am this week with two new additions to the fume family🙄
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahahahahahaha.
LikeLike
LOLOLOL!!!! No judgment here Cassie 🙂
We are all in this together!
LikeLike
oooh, Cassie, I’m so sorry for you 😛
LikeLike
Hi there Brigitte. You have to insist on samples. Firmly. I mean, it is your right as a customer to try something first, right? The SA in the store was particularly nice though, possible a little older than me, making it much easier to have a conversation than with some young one who thinks they know it all, when they actually know very little. I hope you get to try it at some point. And do not let them spray you, do it yourself. I never ever allow that. I vote Misia, although I have not tried the updated version yet. Hugs. xxxxxx
LikeLike
Problem is now, most of them are just not as nice as they were. I cringe hearing myself say that, it is So annoying when perfume people tell you how much better it all was in the olden days. Pittsburgh huh? I have to go to Vienna or Munich if I want an Exclusif counter. Fortunately that is not too often. Although I will head there again in April. And allow my inlays to buy the 1957 for me for Easter. To get around the no buying rule I rather stupidly made myself. Lots of love, Val. xxxxx
LikeLike
Love Misia, not vote. Rolls eyes.
LikeLike
I’ll certainly give myself a good spritz of this if I see it anywhere. I’ll be in a city next month where I know they’ll have it. I live in a perfume wasteland so have to travel to try new stuff that’s not in wide distribution.
LikeLiked by 1 person
One does what one must. 😎
Drop back in here and let us know if you get to try it.
LikeLike
Funny thing is I was so mad for her giving me the wrong sample after all that hooplah to get it that I didn’t even try it but passed it on to my mother!
and Val I have gone so far as to bring my own empty sample vials when they say “we don’t have any samples”…but they won’t even give me the bottles to make my own sample!!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Too much. We‘ll have to go together one day then, 2 against 1. Didn‘t try it? Hahahahaha. Serious anger.
LikeLike
Ha, yes, strength in numbers 🙂 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Plus I carry APJ Cookie Queen business cards, if things get desperate. That usually does it. 😉
LikeLike
Not having access to Les Exclusifs definitely dampens my enthusiasm to try, I still haven’t sniffed most of them, tbh. If someone wants to send me a set of samples I’d be willing 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh MMkinPA – I commented and then posted it above yours. Shit. I really need to look before I push buttons. xxx
LikeLike
I saw it. Pittsburgh is a lovely city for food, but not so much for perfume!! And not close enough to any of the big cities to make shopping trips practical.
LikeLike
You and me both!
LikeLike
Rock bands are so apolitical now, it’s depressing.
Looking forward to getting my nose on this
LikeLiked by 1 person
Brass Against are hardcore political. Yeah, I am waiting desperately to hear your thought on it, despite the fact that I dunno if it is quite your Fortnum´s cup of tea. xxx
LikeLike
A great gig would always win 😉 I’ve only tried five or six of Les Exclusives, liked them enough but still not enough to splash out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I totally agree with you, Diana.
LikeLiked by 1 person
😘 They’re good, though.
LikeLike
Money saved. You now how it goes, don’t love, don’t buy. Oh yaaaaas, I love a good gig. Always have done. xxxxxx
LikeLike
Actually, I have you to thank for this attitude. Before I came to APJ I was too curious buying scents I wasn’t even sure I needed (but then again, the dollar was much cheaper then, lol), and now I’m an aspiring wise Kaa 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Good to hear. Most scents are a total disappointment don’t you think? xxxx
LikeLike
True 😦 but I still believe in miracles 😉
LikeLike
The last gig I have been to was in 1980 or 1979 I think…Van Morrison in a small concert hall in Nijmegen. I have loved his music ever since. I adore many Chanels, and you give it high praise, so if a sample comes my way (only available in Amsterdam so not any time soon) I will give it some serious nose time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi there Hamamelis 🙂 I guess you will make it down to Amsterdam at some point for something huh? I saw someone in Nijmegen and I cannot for the life of me remember who. Hmmmmm. 1980? Oh my gosh. You have better remedy that this year, somehow huh? I saw Van Morrison at one of the very early paying Glastonbury`s. Could even have been in 79 or 80. That would make sense if he was touring. Big bussis. Val xxxxxxx
LikeLike
I adore Van Morrison! Most played music especially while cooking, relaxing, and while walking with my dog, never tire of it. I’ve seen him perform a few times over the years. Sadly I don’t think he’d perform again in the US.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Totally same here. Never tire of it. Always relaxes and uplifts me.
LikeLike
I’m with Diana: good old live bands in smaller venues are the best. Last December I went to Cologne to see Nile Rodgers and his band performing his greatest hits for Chic, Sister Sledge, Daft Punk…it was amazing!
Chanel Exclusives are good but I still didn’t find THE one I couldn’t live without.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hmmmmm – I like a huge gig too, but not stadium size and not festivals. I saw Foo Fighters and MUSE, both in the Vienna Stadthalle. 20,000. We had excellent seats for both. We had seats for BrassAgainst too. I refuse to stand any more. I had years of that. Too much now, and I wanna watch the band, not body slam. Hahahahahaha. George Ezra was cool too. About 4,000.
There is no perfume that I could not live without. Honestly. But I would hate to be without my Vero`s. Really. xxxxxx
LikeLike
I could live without my sense of smell but I couldn’t live without music, that’s for sure.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I also saw Nile and Chic in December. An amazing gig. The crowd ranged from 9 to 90 I think and everyone was having a ball.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have be never seen them, but watched their performance at Glastonbury on telly. They sure got the crowd grooving.
LikeLike
Really? It was fantastic, wasn’t it? They sound live better than in the recordings. I was blown away.
LikeLike
Incredible. Even my hubby who’s more into rock was bopping and was totally impressed.
LikeLike
Ahhhh Vienna! How awesome is it that you can go to a gig like that and buy Chanel perfume Val! I need to figure out a way to get a sample of 1957. No Chanel Exclusifs in Basel.
Sandra xo
LikeLiked by 2 people
We walked down your old street to the gig. The Porgy and Bess. Talked about you all. We had some wonderful times together huh? Wait until I buy a bottle ……. April. xxxxxx
LikeLike
I love live concert music and attend fave bands whenever they come to Denver.. I saw Bob Seger this past weekend, sadly his final tour. He was amazing and performed all his best music. I’ve been a fan forever.
1957! It is a love for me as well (most of the Exclusifs are). I didn’t have the opportunity to sample 1957 prior to purchase online and I had no patience to wait; however, thank you for Val for making it an easy and successful decision for blind buy. Your review is spot on. 1957’s initial burst of aldehydes is such a blissful pleasure, and the orange blossom, with honey, spice, floral, musk evolve dynamically in a translucent and soft comfortable way. Agreed, one must spend time enjoying all aspects fully. I find 1957 light and airy, but with good longevity. I spray lavishly (1957 is never over the top too much). Expertly crafted by Olivier Polge!
My only regret is not buying the large bottle!
PS I also love Venise
LikeLiked by 1 person
But Kathleen! You do not NEED the big bottle. I want it too. Hahahaha. Then I will have three big ones, a nice round number don’t you think? You are right, you can spray a ton of it, lovely. There are so few perfumes I can do that with, with my superglue skin. One of the reasons I love the Eauxs, I can spray forever ….. I most certainly was not trying to aid you in a blind buy. 😉 Still, its great that we both love it, that is very satisfying for perfunistas huh? Hugs, Val xxxxxx
LikeLike
I was on the fence about blind buying, but generally love most Chanel fragrances. Your positive comments helped, I felt fairly certain it would be a good purchase.
It is very enjoyable when fellow perfumistas enjoy fragrances in common; I learn so much from following all of you in this community.
LikeLike
I am not really a Chanel girl, but will give this a sniff when I get a chance. It’s been too long since my last live concert, I plan to rectify that this summer.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rectify the gig thing and let me know please. Sure, try it. You should. It is an excellent piece of perfumery. You will see that ben if it is not what you like to wear. Bussis Ms C. xxxxxxx
LikeLike
I will *definitely* sniff this next time I am anywhere near an Exclusifs counter, and give it proper consideration. It’s something I would have written off from the notes, but you’ve convinced me that it’s well worth trying.
I never go to enough gigs, but I’ve been lucky enough to go to some fabulous ones–all time highlights were probably seeing Godspeed You! Black Emperor years back in London and more recently in Edinburgh, Jesus and Mary Chain last year, Underworld, Sigur Ros in Amsterdam…and, bizarrely, four Georgian Monks singing polyphonic choral and folk songs in an ancient church in the Suffolk countryside…
LikeLiked by 2 people
oh. and thanks again for the Brass Against pointer a while back.
D’you ever listen to Asian Dub Foundation?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have listened to them yep. If I remember correctly I am pretty sure you told me about them. Will put them on the Treadmill Tunes tomorrow. xxxxx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I would love to have seen The Jesus and Mary Chain. Georgian Monks? Why am I not surprised? 🙂
I was really laughing earlier to day, Crikey. You drowned in Bogue and me in white musks. Hahahahahahaha. Try it. Stranger things have happened, not many maybe but …… xxxxx
LikeLiked by 1 person
not drowning but floating, floating gloriously on a sea of Bogue…
Yeah, the monks blew my tiny mind. One of those magic evenings, you know? (That said, I have a real weakness for sung polyphonic music. Beyond goosebumps and chills. It gets right under my skin and into my bones.)
re: ADF… best songs for training, for me: Fortress Europe and Where’s all the money gone
J&MC are touring again, on and off… you never know!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Floating. My mistake. x
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jesus and Mary Chain were my FAVOURITE concert. Saw them in 1994 or 95 in Melbourne. Intimate setting, only an hour on stage, but worth it. The light show, the music…wow!
Last gig was Bliss N Eso in 2014. Had a few of my most loved Aussie hip hoppers – Horrorshow, Seth Sentry. Seth’s gig was outstanding. Played just for us, got everyone involved and had loads of energy. I’d have gone just for him.
Worst was Beastie Boys. Last show in Perth. Volume was so low that we had a conversation without shouting. They really could not be bothered being there. It was 1998. I felt crushed. They are lodged in my heart, alongside Velvet Underground and J.S Bach (organ concerto).
As for 57, the SA put one spritz on a card. I judged it from that. The opening was pretty, but paper amplifies the white musk and it was ALL I got. I confess it disappointed me. But I am by no means a white musk fan at all. So, unless a sample comes my way, I’d rather seek out my Hermés lemming.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I went to a wedding party with the Beastie Boys, LL Cool J, and a host of others in the Dominican Republic. Hmmmm. 1988. The manager or someone big, from DefJam was getting married and they all flew down from NYC. The Beasties were so drunk they just leaned against the posts all night, I don‘t remember them moving. LL Cool J randomly rapped and yeah, was an interesting party.
There is no way you can smell this on a card. It has to have skin. I am not a white musk fan, but this really stunned me. But more importantly – what is your Hermès lemming???
Hugs. Xxxx
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah I would have loved to have seen the Jesus and Mary Chain too. We were supposed to go once and they cancelled if I recall correctly.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, what a disappointment with the Beastie Boys. Still love them, though. Soz.
I think I mentioned a while back about the *first* time I saw the Mary Chain… September 1985 at a shitty club/venue called Clouds in Preston. There’s an audio recording of it on YouTube that I found when I was trying to remember when it was. Rough–complete with hostile hecklers–raw, and alive. Slammed me right back in time.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oh, I still adore the B Boys. They still make me super happy.
LikeLike
OOOOO!!! I would love to see Crikey drowning in white musks! stranger things indeed 😉
LikeLike
fine, fine…i promise that when I encounter it I will try it directly on my skin.
Generously, copiously, lavishly. And report back.
LikeLiked by 1 person
😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s if you don’t go into anaphylactic shock😂
LikeLike
No change of Crikey going into any kind of shock, I promise you. It does need to go on skin though, that is for sure, it is useless on paper. Unlike something like say Coromandel which is pretty much the same glued onto anything, regardless.
LikeLike
chance*
LikeLike
I’m going to have to venture out to try this. It sounds really lovely. As for live shows, used to go all the time. Chicago, where I’ve lived at various times in my life, had great spots. Where I live now, not so much. I envy your hearing The Clash. My best memories are from the late 80s: Husker Du, Sonic Youth, etc.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Hey there Amy! Sonic Youth and Husker Du? Very nice, yeah! I saw the Clash at least 9 times, maybe more. Mick Jones remains my my favourite lyricists, and I listen to the London Calling album regularly in the gym, I mean at east twice a week, Chicago, what a cool place to live. I visited once a. few years ago, just for three days. I long to go back. I rarely go to gigs any more, even if it soundalike it. Hahahaha. Just when something good comes along and we bother to get tickets, and that usually involves a hotel too. A proper event! Yep, it is lovely, grab a spritz or ten when you can. xxxxxx
LikeLike
Yes to the genius of The Clash and truly great for the gym. I have an arsenal from that era for such purposes.
LikeLike
https://australianperfumejunkies.com/2015/01/13/lipstick-perfume-pop-heroes-true-story/
LikeLike
I bloody love this story ❤
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ha, yes they were more interesting times. Or maybe it just seems that way because were young and reckless. We got away with stuff that wouldn’t go under the radar nowadays. 😉
LikeLike
You might get a laugh out of this. Pics gone because of the APJ meltdown last year. But text is still there.
LikeLike
I’d love to know what went on in Amsterdam. But my imagination can probably fill in lots of blanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Brava Val! I adore 1957 and am bemused at the amount of hate it’s getting. It is, as you said, a work of genius.😘😘😘
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hello there Herr R. Of course it is getting hate. Eye roll. As I said, people, in general are kind of dumb.
It’ divine. Of course it won’t be what everyone wants to wear, but I guarantee you if you ask the vocal white musk haters what exactly white musks are, and how they work, their stares would be blank. I love the stuff the Polge is doing. Lots of love to you both. xxxxxx
LikeLike
Hey Val,
I’m not convinced it is a work of genius. There’s too much out there already very like it at a far better price point. I do think they have elevated the genre and that the ingredients used smell far more expensive to a non perfumer.
Yes, I bought the 200ml and yes it will get used. Not because it’s unbelievably amazing but because it’s not. It’s very banality makes it extra wearable in so many situations. I will spritz and go with it whenever I want fragrance but nothing too interesting or overpowering.
Excellent review, as always. I love reading your stuff.
Portia xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi my Honiest Honey! 🙂 It will be interesting to watch how it goes down, I think it is the diamond in the collection. Perfectly cut. Hahahahahaha. “Yes. I bought 200 mls …..” Really? Maybe the fact tha tis supremely wearable, makes it amazing. Time will tell. Meanwhile Chris thinks it is the most gorgeous perfume that I nearly own. Thanks for reading!! Love you. xxxxx
LikeLike
Hi Val love your review waiting to try this 1957 …. today we heard about Karl Lagerfeld.. did he have anything to do with the perfume line I wonder??
The last show I went to was Donny Benet .. a euro pop Italian Australian who has been touring around European clubs last couple years and they love him! I really enjoyed myself at his show in October! Very good songs and as we Aussies say ., taking the piss.. loved it!!! Also the Whitlams a very political band .. saw them and they were wonderful as usual … love live shows 😘
LikeLike
No. Absolutely nothing to do with their perfumes at all, as far as I know. I think you may have told me about this Donny Benet huh? I just missed his European tour. I am sure you can find someone from the inner circle to let you try the 1957, huh? Whitlams? Google time. Bussis and hugs. xxxxxxxx
LikeLike
A great gig excites me as you know ;), and this new Chanel does too, even if I am a bit wary of musks. It sounds very refined, and a new classic.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I reckon you might well love it. And it will prove to be a stunning classic, a jewel in the Chanel crown. I do believe I have a rough idea of how much a good gig excites you. 😉 xxxxxxx
LikeLike
The last gig I saw was the Tex-Mex band Calexico. I was standing right next to the stage, eyeballing the trumpeter. It was awesome; they are a great band with about 20 years worth of albums to pick a set list from. I also saw comedy duo Lano and Woodley the other night, which was also fun.
I really want to try 1957, because it is my birth year. If i really like it, I might just splurge on myself for a birthday present. Bit I’d have to REALLY like it, at Chanel prices.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey Greg! Nice to see you. I don’t know the band but will take a look.
Try 1957 and see. Ignore the crap reviews out there, hahahahaha – people don’t get it. And let me know. 1959 was my year. 💋
LikeLike
I’ve just received a 10ml decant of 1957 and now I have to go the FB, pity I didn’t know about it when we were in Paris last November. Love a good gig and still get to as many possible, saw the Chili Peppers on Sunday night with 50,000 of my closest friends 😆 they were the big act for Adelaide’s V8 supercar race that we have here every year. Faves over the years have been Bowie, Prince, Foo Fighters and the best ever Aussie band Midnight Oil. If you get the chance to see the Oils live do it!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Never saw Bowie, well except when he walked onto do a song with Lou Reed in London, donkey’s years ago. Saw the Chili Peppers on their Blood Sugar Sex Magic Tour 1991, or was it 1990. Saw the Foo Fighters a couple of years ago, and will
LikeLike
Make every effort to see Midnight Oil if I ever get the chance. Absolutely.
Ah! You love 1957? I’m nearly out of my mini. Will get an actual thunk out of it. And buy a bottle on April 4th when there is 20% off. Thanks for dropping by chrissyinoz. ❤️
LikeLike
20% off???? WHERE????
LikeLike