Heya Frag Hags,
Recently I was over at my mate Bronwyn’s house. She has so much going on with new Gascoigne & King candles, a brand new concept I can’t tell you about and the exciting release in Australia of ELdO’s Don’t Get Me Wrong Baby, Yes I Do. There are plenty of rumours flying about but I haven’t heard anything definitive about what’s happened to the original but perusing the Etat Libre d’Orange site it has been taken off the shopping list.
Don’t Get Me Wrong Baby, Yes I Do by Etat Libre d’Orange 2016
Don’t Get Me Wrong Baby, Yes I Do by Antoine Maisondieu
Fragrantica gives these featured accords:
Orange blossom, lily-of-the-valley, patchouli, jasmine, aldehydes, amber, cacao pod, marshmallow, musk
The note list has not changed between the old and new but I’m wondering if they have tweaked the formula at all. The good news is I have a bottle of both here so I can do a fragrant throwdown. Let’s do it together.
Yes I Do v I Don’t Swallow
Firstly, the new bottle is so bloody pretty. Shimmery, like an old fashioned nail polish. Match that with the gold sticker and it’s all very budget line from a high fashion company, aimed at the young. It feels very Love Moschino, Juicy Couture or Lauren Ralph Lauren. The fun, affordable brands aiming directly at the market I imagine this will also hit.
Both open with a sheer soft focus Lily of the Valley (LotV), sweetness added by the marshmallow and a very youthful, clean jasmine/orange blossom. If you like your LotV Diorissimo style then you’ll be disappointed. Here we have a much less strident rendition, no screech, just pillowed clouds. The two fragrances smell pretty similar to me, not much change. They may have added, tweaked and subtracted some stuff but it hasn’t changed the ultimate ride. I do like spritzing from the new bottle better though because it’s so fun.
Personally, I don’t get a lot of the oft hyped funk that this scent was purporting to display. All I get is a bit of plasticky patchouli, some extra depth and warmth coming through towards the end but I’m still smelling soft wafts of LotV which keeps the whole scent fresh, youthful and prim.
Sephora will have Yes I Do in Australia
Etat Libre d’Orange has €85/50ml (Shipping to the world only €15)
Want to check the difference for yourself? I’d love to hear if you think it has changed.
Yes I Do v I Don’t Swallow GIVEAWAY
WHAT CAN YOU WIN?
This week there will be 3 winners who will receive:
1 x 10ml decant Yes I Do
1 x 10ml decant I Don’t Swallow
P&H Anywhere in the world
HOW DO YOU WIN?
Open to everyone worldwide who follows AustralianPerfumeJunkies via eMail, WordPress, Bloglovin or RSS. Please leave how you follow in the comments to be eligible. I must be able to check that you follow so if you have an email address on your gravatar that’s different to your follow address then please email me so I know. Yes, you can start following to enter, in fact it’s encouraged.
You must tell me how you follow APJ
Please tell us which name sounds best to you?
Entries Close Wednesday 21st June 2017 10pm Australian EdsT and winners will be announced in a separate post.
Winners will be chosen by random.org
The winners will have till Wednesday 28th June 2017 to get in touch (portia underscore turbo at yahoo dot com dot au) with their address or the prize will go to someone else.
No responsibility taken for lost or damaged goods in transit
25 thoughts on “Don’t Get Me Wrong Baby, Yes I Do by Antoine Maisondieu for Etat Libre d’Orange 2016”
Yes I Do of course! I follow via email AND FB!
Hi Portia, and thanks for the giveaway. I follow by email.
I like ‘Yes I Do’ … because it could mean anything.
Yes I Do has the positive vibes for me! Follow by email. 🙂
I don’t understand what this swallow angle has to do with perfume, but YES I DO want to win this prize. 🙂 I follow by e-mail.
I follow via email and Facebook.
I prefer the name Yes, I do, but if you ask me which I personally prefer to do, I would say, I don’t swallow. TMI. LOL
Yes I Do
Follow via Bloglovin.
I’d have to say Yes I Do. Thanks so much. I follow by email.
Yes I do would probably sell better, email
I follow via email. I like the new version for both the bottle and the name. Yes I Do! Thanks for the giveaway.
Follow via mail and facebook. I like the dont version better lol
I follow via email. I like “Yes I do” better. =)
Frankly I find both names very crass, but they are the people who gave us Putain des Palaces, so I should have expected nothing else. I prefer the old name because it has more spine.
I follow by email. Thanks for the draw! I’ve been quite curious since the new one came out. Not sure I like the bottle, though.
I find the newer name better because the swallow part in the older one is a bit, I don’t know, cheesy maybe. I follow APJ through email and Facebook.
I prefer ‘yes I do’, other name is a bit smutty. I follow by email.
Yes I Do sounds better to me, I would have a hard time telling someone the name of the fragrance I am wearing is called I Don’t Swallow! I follow by email!
Yes I Do sounds so innocent unless someone knows the full name of the original. I’ll go for the original in recognition of ELDO’s deliberate cheekiness when they started up.
I follow by email. Thanks for the draw.
Follow by email, I prefer “Yes I Do”. The original was cheeky and cute for a bit, but then got a little tired and not so cutting-edge anymore. Thanks! Xoxo
i follow by email.
i like “yes i do”.
I don’t swallow came first?
I follow by email “yes I do”
Yes I Do. The other one has got sleazy connotation to it even if unintended. I follow via your BLOG and email. Cheers Portia.
‘I don’t swallow sounds more ELDO style))
I follow by email.
I follow via email and i would prefer ‘Yes I do’. I think the original is more ELDO. I actually wore it the other day. Such a cheeky name for a scent that is so innocent!
I kinda prefer the ‘shock value’ of original name…..just tickled my fancy
I follow via Twitter and facebook.
Thank you for the opportunity to try each perfume.
I prefer the ambiguity of ‘Yes I Do’.
Thanks for the draw; I follow by email.
Ha! I love I Dont Swallow. Just to be contrary
I hope I can sneak in! I never get a chance to check my blogs til I get home. I follow via Feedly RSS
Comments are closed.